WARNING! THIS POST CONTAINS EXTREME BATHROOM DISCUSSION. IF YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE POOP, GET OFF THE CRAPPER!

I know kids don’t usually go to Kindergarten crapping their pants. I also know kids don’t move into a college dorm still wetting the bed. Well, they might. That would be a time to talk about drinking in moderation. But, I’m starting to think I started my daughter potty training too early.
We followed the pediatrician’s advice to buy a potty for a little girl when she turns 18 months. We did. We talked about the potty. We brushed her teeth on the potty. She pushed the buttons on the potty that made funny noises. She thought the potty was great
When she turned 2 in November we bought Pull-Ups and she was delighted. She didn’t want diapers anymore. She was psyched.
After the holidays, when Santa brought panties, it was on like Donky Kong. Potty training. Boo yah! She wears panties at school except for her nap. At home we try to keep panties on until it’s time for bed. When we go somewhere, though, it’s back in a Pull-Up.
Number one is usually not a problem. Number two. Ugh! Still a battle EVERYDAY! I feel like I’m always dumping little turds from Minnie Mouse underpants into the commode. I lead a glamorous life, lemme tell ya.
We’ve tried the “one M&M for pee and two for poop.” We’ve tried the “one sticker on the chart for pee and two for poop.” We’ve caved in to poor parenting tactics and bribed her with toys. She has only pooped on toilet a handful of times and it was really just good timing on our part because we detected a pre-poop fart and ran her in the bathroom.
I’ve heard of 3 1/2 year-olds who still won’t take a crap unless it’s in their Pull-Up or diaper. I don’t want that to happen to us. I know she can do it, she just doesn’t want to stop playing long enough to go.
What am I doing wrong here? Should I ditch the Pull-Up for naptime and bedtime too, and hope when she wakes in her own filth she’ll get the picture? That seems cruel and like something they would do to prisoners in captivity, you know?
Where are we going wrong? Should we have just done the extreme roll-up-the-rug-and-let-them-run-naked method? Is she just too young? What did you do?
Thanks!